No new workable plans for Senate reform

Current advertisements trumpeting Justin Trudeau’s new plans to reform the Senate point to the Liberal party’s website. A search of the website lists the plan, as it were, which is still the Liberal leader’s late January pronouncement that all Liberal Senators had to leave the party and sit as independents.

Let’s face it, calling for correction and change at the Senate, or even abolition, is a “can’t lose” proposition, no matter what the party, because only one third of Canadians now support the Senate It’s like asking Canadians: “Do you want to pay less taxes?” Most recognize the problems with the upper house, and we’re all acquainted with the largesse and scandals of the past two years, i.e. Mike Duffy, Pamela Wallin, Patrick Brazeau and Mac Harb. For those paying attention, there have been problems in the Red Chamber for decades, including the infamous Andy Thompson. Appointed in 1967 by

Lester Pearson, Thompson who resigned in 1998, just after becoming the first Senator ever to be disciplined for truancy. He lived most of the time in Mexico.

Support for the Senate now currently rides at about one third. Most Canadians indicate they prefer voting for Senators, with that support around 70 per cent.

On the website, Trudeau states: “If I am elected Prime Minister, I will put in place an open, transparent and non-partisan appointment process for Senators. This process will be developed working with experts and informed by other non-partisan appointment processes.

“Further, as the majority party in the Senate, immediate and comprehensive change is in Conservative hands. I’m calling on the Prime Minister to do the right thing and join us in ending patronage and partisanship in the Senate. All he needs is the judgment and will to get it done.”

Taking a look at what is there, the nonpartisan appointment process sounds interesting, but it would remain to be seen if a sitting PM could resist the temptation to appoint non-party members to positions where they could vote against the ruling party’s legislation.

Besides, the democratic process ensures that there will always be something resembling balance in the Senate. Liberal PMs appoint Liberal Senators. Conservative PMs appoint Conservative Senators. Of the 105 total Senate seats right now, the Conservatives have 57, although there are 9 vacancies and 7 independents.

Liberal PM Jean Chretien named 75 Senators, and Conservative PM Stephen Harper is closing in at 59. Trudeau’s father, Pierre, appointed 81.

As for Trudeau’s call for “immediate and comprehensive change,” Harper attempted that, but was redirected by the Supreme

Court to the real target if change is to be realized: The provinces and the Constitution.

The ruling re-clarified an important point: The prime minister simply cannot make change of this magnitude just because he wants to. He must obtain near consensus from the provinces.

Re-opening the constitution is also necessary, but that means re-opening old wounds and re-examining a process that sees Prince Edward Island with four Senators. Vancouver Island, twice the size of PEI with five times the population, has none.

The Senate is supposed to provide an important function by taking a sober second look at legislation.

But if it doesn’t and the only way to reform it is to re-open the constitution, then while it’s open, why not go all the way and just eliminate it altogether? -Vancouver Island NewsMedia Group

Just Posted

Tofino mayor cheers provincial government’s plastics survey

Mayors of Tofino, Victoria, Squamish and Rossland collaborate on letter.

Youth lead Ucluelet Cemetery nameplate project

Students navigate maps and scour local archives over three years to honour deceased.

Tofino awards $2.4M contract to connect path to Pacific Rim National Park Reserve

The district announced the project will be paid entirely with grants.

Semi-truck crashes on Hwy. 4 between Port Alberni and Tofino-Ucluelet

Drivers heading in or out of Tofino-Ucluelet Friday afternoon should expect delays

Clean the house, prep for your next trip: Tips to nix the post-vacation blues

48 per cent of travellers are already stressed about ‘normal life’ while still on their trip

Vancouver Island senior found safe with help from six search and rescue teams

Wayne Strilesky found safe in thick brush in north Nanaimo

More women may need breast cancer gene test, U.S. guidelines say

Recommendations aimed at women who’ve been treated for BRCA-related cancers and are now cancer-free

Couple could go to jail for taking 88 lbs. of Italian sand

Pair said they didn’t know it was illegal to take the sand, which is protected as a public good

Bodies of two missing Surrey men found near Ashcroft: RCMP

Ryan Provencher and Richard Scurr have been missing since July 17

B.C. manhunt suspects left cellphone video before they died: family

Family member says Kam McLeod, Bryer Schmegelsky recorded final wishes

VIDEO: RCMP unveil new, state-of-the-art forensics lab

The laboratory is expected to handle thousands of forensic services from across Canada annually

Scheer promises EI tax credit for new parents if Conservatives form government

The government currently taxes employment insurance benefits for new parents

Most Read