Plans for former church featured in ‘Man of Steel’ on hold as district, developer lock horns

Smack in the middle of Ucluelet sits a building without a purpose.

The district’s concerns over liability issues have stalled an application that would see the building formerly known as St. Aidan’s on the Hill church become an event venue.

The building’s owner Leif Hagar told the Westerly News last week that he still hopes to hold events on the building’s main floor with four retail units on the bottom floor but the district has, temporarily at least, cut the development’s legs off.

“The building permit application was made at the end of November last year, initially it appeared straight forward, however, weeks later in the process, an additional requirement was made by the district which has crippled this project,” Hagar said.

“I am still exploring my limited options due to the fact this building is now a liability, not an opportunity, for this community.”

The former church rests atop Main Street and was once the backdrop for a scene in the Superman movie Man of Steel but currently serves only as a memory-beacon for locals and a cool place for tourists to have their picture taken.

Community members built the church in 1952 but a dwindling congregation led to it being deconsecrated in 2010 and sold to Hagar for about $185,000 in 2011, as reported by former Westerly staffer Julia Prinselaar.

Hagar hoped to turn the building into an event-venue and in December 2011 it hosted an album-launch party for Ucluelet band Left at the Junction.

Shortly after the party, Hagar heard from the district office that such community gatherings could not be held in the building because its zoning only allowed for a private school, place of worship, or community care facility.

The zoning issue became contentious and resulted in Hagar circulating a petition in 2012 calling for the district’s manager of planning Patricia Abdulla to be removed from office. After a back and forth haggling-marathon between Hagar and the district, an accord seemed to have been struck in July 2013 when Ucluelet Mayor Bill Irving told the Westerly News the two sides had “worked collectively to not only do the rezoning but the development permit and the development variance permit as well.”

A public hearing was held on July 16 2013 where Hagar presented the district with a petition holding 166 signatures in favour of his application.

During the hearing, two letters of opposition were read with both expressing concern over inadequate parking in the area.

Almost exactly one year after this public hearing took place, the former church remains in flux and once-loosened tensions are re-tightening. Mayor Irving told the Westerly News last week that the district is “very interested in this project moving ahead,” but cannot sign off on what Hagar is proposing because of liability concerns.

Hagar’s application did not cut the mustard in the eyes of West Coast building inspector Bob Schantz whose findings were backed up by an inspector the district brought in from Port Alberni, according to Irving.

“We brought a second building inspector in from Port Alberni just to make sure that what we’re presenting is correct and he affirmed that ‘yes’ there had to be changes,” Irving said.

He said an engineer must sign off on the building’s ability to host the events and retail units Hagar’s plan entails before the district can move forward with the application.

“The engineer has to be satisfied that that’s a safe building and he’ll put his stamp of approval on it and then the application is covered off,” Irving said. “At the end of the day we really want a successful building there with no liability attached to it.”

He said Hagar recently went through the former church with a building inspector and an engineer in an effort to hash out potential options.

“Hopefully these steps that are in process now lead to a resolution and not frustration,” he said.

Frustration is looming as the church sits idle in the middle of town but Irving said the district must yield to potential liability concerns before merging with developers.

“We certainly would like businesses to be able to come in and be successful and we work very hard at that but the caveat is the district is not going to hold the liability. If we put our stamp on a building that is defective and somebody’s injured then the district, the taxpayers, the residents, pay the price,” Irving said.

“It’s far better for both the developer and ourselves to make sure all those issues are resolved before occupancy is allowed than (it is to) try to catch up with it afterwards because it’s cost us hundreds of thousands of dollars in the past when we’ve approved stuff without being very careful about the liability.”

reporter@westerlynews.ca

Just Posted

‘Police are ready’ for legal pot, say Canadian chiefs

But Canadians won’t see major policing changes as pot becomes legal

VIDEO: Rescued eagle released in Ucluelet

“I’m very confident that he’s going to make it. He’s done very well.”

Ahousaht Fire Department always at the ready

“Under stressful situations we come out at our best.”

Tofino honours volunteer firefighters with award

To have the community support you, say ‘Thank you,’ and recognize you, just really means an awful lot

UPDATE: Sea lion rescued in Ucluelet suffering from gunshot to the head

“It does look like there’s some pretty serious metal density in his skull.”

Video: An up-close look at beluga whales in Hudson Bay

An up-close look as some belugas greet whale watchers off the coast of Churchill, Manitoba

Sockeye run in Shuswap expected to be close to 2014 numbers

Salute to the Sockeye on Adams River continues until Sunday, Oct. 21 at 4 p.m.

Michelle Mungall’s baby first in B.C. legislature chamber

B.C. energy minister praises support of staff, fellow MLAs

Canucks: Pettersson in concussion protocol, Beagle out with broken forearm

Head coach Travis Green called the hit ‘a dirty play’

5 tips for talking to your kids about cannabis

Health officials recommend sharing a harm reduction-related message.

NHL players say Canada’s legalization of marijuana won’t impact them

NHL players say the legalization of marijuana in Canada won’t change how they go about their business.

Automated cars could kill wide range of jobs, federal documents say

Internal government documents show that more than one million jobs could be lost to automated vehicles, with ripple effects far beyond the likeliest professions.

Private marijuana stores should shut down, Mike Farnworth says

B.C. has approved 62 licences, but they still need local approval

HPV vaccine does not lead to riskier sex among teen girls: UBC

Girls are less likely to have sex now than they were a decade ago

Most Read